Michigan Community Mental Health Services
CMHSP expenditures per client as reported in DCH's fiscal year-1998 Boilerplate report
to the Legislature were distributed to persons with developmental disabilities at
approximately $26,000 per client, to adults with mental illness at roughly $3,900 per
client, and to minors with emotional disorders at about $2,550.

BACKGROUND ON MICHIGAN'S PUBLICLY FUNDED MENTAL HEALTH SYSTEM

Michigan's publicly funded mental health system is a community mental health system supervised by
the Department of Community Health (DCH). Forty-nine Community Mental Health Services Programs
(CMHSPs), connected to county government by existing state law, act as gatekeepers to various treatment
and support services for adults with mental illnesses, minors with emotional disorders and developmentally
disabled individuals. Some of these services are provided directly by CMHSPs, while others occur by
contracts arranged by the CMHSPs. During the 1998 state fiscal year, CMHSPs reported serving 206,000
consumers. Of these, approximately 66% were adults with mental illnesses, roughly 20% were minors with
emotional disorders and about 14% were individuals with developmental disabilities. During that same
period, DCH reported that less than half of CMHSP service recipients were enrolled in Medicaid. Forty-
five percent of adults and minors with mental illness/emotional disorders were Medicaid enrollees,
compared to over 65% of individuals with developmental disabilities. In the state fiscal year-2000 budget
the Legislature has assigned $1.7 billion to Michigan's CMHSPs, with $1.2 billion of this amount to be
allocated to Medicaid care.


For the last few years, CMHSP expenditures for the three major disability classifications served by the
system have been distributed approximately as 35% to adults with mental illness, 7-8% to minors with
emotional disorders, 48-49% to persons with developmental disabilities and 8-10% for administrative
overhead and other costs (see Table 1). Under current state law, CMHSPs are directed to give prioritized,
not necessarily exclusive, attention to individuals with the most severe forms of mental illness, emotional
disorder and developmental disability, as well as assist any persons experiencing an emergency/urgent
situation related to any of these three classifications. CMHSPs are required to at least provide the
following services and activities within their community:


1) Crisis response and stabilization which may include the use of an inpatient psychiatric setting or
an alternative protective treatment environment;

2) Case identification, assessment and diagnosis;


3) Service planning, coordination, monitoring and follow-up through individualized service plans
which employ a person-centered planning process;

4) Specialized consumer training, treatment and support;

 Table 1. Statewide CMHSP Expenditures by Recipient Group and Other Categories, DCH Annual Budget Submissions to Legislature, 1995-1999.
Date of Submission to Legislature % for Minors w/ Emotional Disorder % for Adults w/ Mental Illness % for Persons w/ Developmental Disabilities % for Administration % for Prevention &/or "Other"
 04/13/99  7.8%  35.5%  48.5%  2.4%  5.7%
 02/17/98  7.8%  33.2%  49.4%  6.0%  3.6%
 03/11/97  8.0%  36.4%  46.1%  5.6%  3.8%
 02/27/96  8.4%  33.8%  48.5%  6.6%  2.8%
 04/27/95  7.8%  35.3%  49.1%  6.2%  1.6%

5) Mental health advocacy;

6) Diversion programs for persons mentally ill who may face incarceration in jails;

7) Prevention activities to inform and educate consumers, family members and citizens about mental illness.


Presently CMHSPs have at their disposal five state-operated psychiatric hospitals. Northville, Walter
Reuther, Kalamazoo and Caro Psychiatric Hospitals serve mentally ill adults and Hawthorn Center serves
emotionally disturbed minors. Southgate and Mt. Pleasant Centers care for the developmentally disabled. In
addition, the state has two forensic inpatient facilities. The Forensic Center serves the courts directly on
issues regarding mental illness and mentally ill offenders. Huron Valley Center treats mentally ill inmates
of the Michigan Department of Corrections.


Ten Department of Community Health psychiatric hospitals were closed during the 1990s (see Table 2).
An important factor which led to this reduction was a state government policy implemented in the early
1980s to apply managed care-like funding procedures to CMHSP use of the state hospitals. In October,
1998, Michigan implemented a more formal, extensive managed care program for CMHSP clients. Under
this program, it is possible that by October 2002 there will be fewer service regions across the state than the
current 49 represented by the present CMHSPs.

Michigan has 1.4 million adults with various forms of mental illness. The federal Center for Mental
Health Service has projected between 253,000 to 485,000 Michigan adults have "serious mental illness."
Using different methods, DCH projects about 140,000 adults in the state have serious disorders.
Based on CMHSPs' reports since 1997, in any given quarter CMHSPs serve between 50,000 to 60,000
adults meeting DCH's criteria for "serious mental disorder." During the 1997 fiscal year, 74,524 out of
130,740 adults served by CMHSPs or 57% met the criteria for seriousness.

 Table 2. Michigan Department of Community Health Psychiatric Hospital Closures, 1990's
 Year  Facility  Age Group(s) Served
 1991 Arnell Engstrom (Traverse City) Minors
York Woods (Ypsilanti) Minors
Ypsilanti Regional Adults
 1992 Coldwater Regional Geriatrics
Newberry Regional Adults
Lafayette Clinic (Detroit) All age groups; also a research and training facility
 1996 Fairlawn Center (Pontiac) Minors
 1997 Clinton Valley Center (Pontiac) Adults
Detroit Psychiatric Institute Adults and Minors
Pheasant Ridge (Kalamazoo)  Minors


T
he Department of Community Health roughly estimates that 300,000 Michigan minors, or 11.8% of
state youth, have a "serious emotional disturbance." The Department reported that CMHSPs served 45,390
or 15% of these youngsters during fiscal year-1998. National estimates of the prevalence of emotional
disturbance among minors vary somewhat. The highest estimates assess 20% of our youth have emotional
disorders. The Methodology for Epidemiology of Mental Disorders in Children and Adolescents Study has
projected that 11% of youngsters between nine and seventeen have mental illness with "signifcant"
functional impairment while 5% have "extreme" impairment.

 

 

 U.S. Surgeon General (Dec '99) US Children and adolescents ages 9 to 17
with mental or addictive disorders
 

 Prevalence (%)
 Anxiety disorders

 13.0
 Mood disorders

 6.2
 Disruptive disorders

 10.3
 Substance use disorders

 2.0
 Any disorder

 20.9

 

 U.S. Surgeon General (Dec '99) Best estimate prevalence rates, US population
 

 Ages 18-54

 Ages 55+

 Best Estimate (%)

 Pevalence (%)
 Any Anxiety Disorder

 16.4

 11.4
 Simple Phobia

 8.3

 7.3
 Social Phobia

 2.0

 1.0
 Agoraphobia

 4.9

 4.1
 GAD

 3.4
 Panic Disorder

 1.6

 0.5
 Obsessive-Compulsive

 2.4

 1.5
 PTSD

 3.6
 
     
 Any Mood Disorder

 7.1

 4.4
 Major Depressive Episode

 6.5

 3.8
 Unipolar MD

 5.3

 3.7
 Dysthymia

 1.6

 1.6
 Bipolar I

 1.1

 0.2
 Bipolar II

 0.6

 0.1
     
 Shizophrenia

 1.3

 0.6
 Nonaffective Psychosis

 0.2
 Somatization

 0.2

 0.3
 Antisoocial Personality Disorder

 2.1

 0.0
 Anorexia Nervosa

 0.1

 0.0
 Severe Congenitive Imparement

 1.2

 6.6
     
 Any Disorder

 21.0

 19.8

 

 Fiscal Year-98 Summary Data on Certain Housing Services in
Michigan's Publicly Funded Mental Health System
 Criterion

 Persons with Mental Illness

 Persons with Developmental Disability
Annual # Specialized Residential Beds Available

 >3,800

 >8,800
Percentage with Primary Residence of Specialized Group Home

 2%

 15%
Percentage with Primary Residence of Alternative Intermediate Services / Mental Retardation Facility

 <1%

 6%
Percentage with Primary Residence of General Group Home

 3%

 11%
Expected Contractural Obligation of CMHSPs for Board-Managed Residential

 $116 million
(625 contracts)

 $363 million
(1,427 contracts)
Percentage of Annual Clientele Equivalent to # of Available Supported Semi-Independent Living Slots

 <1%

 6%

 

 

 

The Prevalence of Mental Disorder in Michigan Prisons 7-2-87

  A final report submitted to the Michigan Department of Corrections by
Harold W. Neighbors, PhD ; Donald H. Williams, MD ;
Thomas S Gunnings, PhD ; Wanda D. Lipscomb, PhD ;
Clifford Broman, PhD ; James Lepkowski, PhD

 SCID DSM-III-R Axis I Primary Diagnoses for Total Prison Population
 Disorder

  Percent

  N
 MOOD DISORDER 

 22.7

 4,600
 Bipolar

 5.4

 1,087
 Other Bipolar

 1.2

 242
 Major Depression

 12.8

 2,599
 Dysthymic Disorder

 3.0

 602
 Depressive Disorder NOS

 1.4

 275
 PSYCHOTIC DISORDERS

 4.6

 922
 Schizophrenia

 4.3

 866
 Schizophreniform Disorder

 0.0

 0
 Schizoaffective Disorder

 0.2

 43
 Delusional Disorders

 0.0

 0
 Brief Reactive Psychosis

 0.0

  0
 Psychotic Disorder NOS

 0.1

 14

 PSYCHOACTIVE SUBSTANCE DEPENDENCE AND ABUSE DISORDERS

 23.8 

 4,810
 Alcohol

 10.8

 2,195
 Sedative-Hypnotic Axiolytic

 0.2

 36
 Cannabis

 5.9

 1,204
 Stimulant

 0.0

 0
 Opioid

 1.9

 381
 Cocaine

 0.3

 64
 Hall. PCP

 0.0

 0
 Poly

 3.6

 725
 Other Drug

 0.0

 0
 ANXIETY DISORDERS

 5.4

 1,086
 Panic Disorder

 0.2

  42
 Agoraphobia without history of Panic Disorder (AWOPD)

 1.3 

 264
 Social Phobia

 0.2

 47
 Simple Phobia

 2.8

 569
 Obsessive Compulsive

 0.5

 92
 Generalized Anxiety

 0.4

 72
 SOMATOFORM DISORDERS

  0.0

 0
 EATING DISORDERS

 0.1

 24
 Anorexia Nervosa

 0.0

 0
 Bulimia Nervosa

  0.1

 24
 OTHER    
 Adjustment disorder

 1.3

 272
 Other DSM-III R Axis I Disorder

 6.1

 1,238
     
 Total with Axis I Primary Diagnosis

 64.0

 12,953
 Total with no Axis I Primary Diagnosis

 36.0

 7,286

 

 

 

 DCH Three-County Jail Study, February 1999
Axis I Diagnostic Classification of Inmates

 Clinton County Jail

 Kent County Jail

 Wayne County Jail

 All Three Jails
Schizophrenia & Psychotic Disorders

 6%

 9%

 7%

 8%
Bipolar Disorders

 6%

 19%

 23%

 18%
Major Depressive Disorders

 5%

 12%

 9%

 8%
Anxiety Disorders

 1%

 5%

 10%

 7%
Adjustment Disorders

 16%

 0%

 6%

 6%
Substance Abuse Disorders

 51%

 38%

 20%

 33%
Other Disorders

 12%

 2%

 1%

 4%
Malingering

 0%

 0%

 0.5%

 0.36%
Normal

 4%

 15%

 24%

 18%

 

 

 Source:
The Mental Health Association in Michigan

Public information - Copy as you please

http://www.mha-mi.org/backgrd.html

 

 

Home Page | About Us | literature | News & Views | Events | Contact Us | Links

.